Marco Rubio on immigration

He promisedno amnesty.Then hewrote it.

Donald Trump called him “the king of amnesty.” This is the file: what he promised, what he wrote, who he listened to, and what he said when voters found out.

2010

What he promised

“Earned path to citizenship is basically code for amnesty.”

Marco Rubio CNN debate, running for the Senate, October 2010

He ran as the conservative in that race. Florida Republicans took him at his word and sent him to Washington.

PolitiFact, Jan. 29, 2016. NPR, Feb. 1, 2013.

2013

What he wrote

He wrote it with Schumer.

Two years into his term he was one of eight senators writing a path to citizenship. By the Congressional Budget Office’s count, 24 million legalized or added by 2033. Chuck Schumer, on who shaped it: “His fingerprints are all over that bill.”

NPR, April 18, 2013. Schumer to CNN, reported by The Hill, Nov. 2015.

Legalization first. The border later.

His own description of the bill, on Univision: “First comes the legalization. Then come the measures to secure the border.” He added that the legalization “is not conditional.”

Univision, “Al Punto,” June 9, 2013. Washington Examiner, June 10, 2013.

Border first? He voted to kill it.

Chuck Grassley of Iowa offered the fix: no legal status until the border had been under control for six months. Rubio voted with Harry Reid to kill the amendment.

Senate vote on Grassley amendment 1195, June 13, 2013. Washington Examiner, same day.

Three out of four would still come.

The Congressional Budget Office scored his bill. Its finding: future illegal immigration would fall by about 25 percent. The rest keeps coming.

Congressional Budget Office, June 18, 2013. The Washington Times, same day.

2013

Who he listened to

The ICE agents say he misled them.

The head of the ICE officers’ union got a meeting the night before the bill was filed. None of his changes went in. The next day he was removed from the Gang of Eight’s press conference for asking a question. His verdict on Rubio: he “directly misled law enforcement officers.”

The Washington Times, June 24, 2013. Breitbart, April 27, 2013. NumbersUSA, April 2013.

Zuckerberg paid for the ads.

Mark Zuckerberg’s political group put seven figures behind TV ads built on clips of Rubio, made to sell the bill to conservative voters in Iowa, Texas, Florida and three other states.

Politico, via Mediaite, April 2013. FactCheck.org, May 2013.

American workers “can’t cut it.”

That is a Rubio aide explaining the bill’s guest-worker program to The New Yorker: “There are American workers who, for lack of a better term, can’t cut it.”

The New Yorker, June 24, 2013.

2004 to 2015

It was never just one bill

In-state tuition for illegal immigrants.

In the Florida House, in 2003 and 2004, he co-sponsored it. Asked in 2016 whether he still stood by that bill, he said he “absolutely” did.

The Daily Beast, Jan. 6, 2016. The Blaze, Jan. 10, 2016.

Dreamers: citizenship on the fast track.

His 2013 bill gave illegal immigrants who came as children a green card in five years and the right to apply for citizenship the same day. It set no age limit: someone who arrived at 10 and was now 60 qualified.

S. 744, section 2103. American Immigration Lawyers Association summary, 2013. Colorlines, April 2013.

End DACA on day one? Not him.

Other Republicans running in 2016 promised to end Obama’s order their first day. Asked on Univision what he would do as president, Rubio said: “I wouldn’t undo it immediately.”

Univision transcript, April 2015. PolitiFact, Feb. 17, 2016.

Still for a path to citizenship.

November 2015, running for president and talking tough, he told NPR he still favored one. He called it “a very long path.”

NPR, Nov. 11, 2015.

2016

What he said when voters found out

His excuse: it was never meant to pass.

He wrote the bill, pitched it on seven Sunday shows and voted for it. Then he told primary voters it was “not what ultimately needed to become law.” Jeff Sessions, who led the fight against it, answered that it nearly became law.

BuzzFeed News, Dec. 2015. NBC News, Feb. 15, 2016. Breitbart, Feb. 16, 2016.

The verdict

From the man who beat him

“If you look at Rubio, he is the king of amnesty.”

Donald Trump November 2015

“Rubio is very, very weak on illegal immigration.”

Donald Trump December 2015

The Washington Times, Nov. 20, 2015. Washington Examiner, Dec. 2015.

In 2010, Republicans took him at his word.

Not twice. Sign the petition

The paper trail

  1. 2010PolitiFact, “Did Marco Rubio flip flop on amnesty?” Jan. 29, 2016
  2. 2010NPR, “What’s Behind Rubio’s ‘Full Circle Back’ On Immigration?” Feb. 1, 2013
  3. 2013NPR, “Gang Of 8 Champion Plan, Declare ‘Year Of Immigration Reform,’” April 18, 2013
  4. 2013The Hill, “Schumer: Rubio’s fingerprints ‘all over’ immigration bill with citizenship path,” Nov. 2015
  5. 2013Breitbart, “‘First Comes the Legalization’: Rubio Contradicts Tough-Talking Immigration Ads,” June 10, 2013
  6. 2013Washington Examiner, “Marco Rubio: In immigration reform, legalization comes first,” June 10, 2013
  7. 2013Washington Examiner, “Marco Rubio votes with Democrats to kill border security before legalization,” June 13, 2013
  8. 2013Sen. Grassley, “Comment on Vote to Table Border Security First Amendment,” June 13, 2013
  9. 2013The Washington Times on the Congressional Budget Office score, June 18, 2013
  10. 2013The Washington Times, “ICE union says Sen. Marco Rubio misled police,” June 24, 2013
  11. 2013Breitbart, “Rubio Touts Talk with ICE Official Which Spurred No Changes to Immigration Bill,” April 27, 2013
  12. 2013NumbersUSA, “ICE Union Pres. removed from Gang of Eight press conference,” April 2013
  13. 2013Mediaite, citing Politico, on the ad campaign: Texas, Florida, Utah, North Carolina, Iowa and Kentucky, April 2013
  14. 2013FactCheck.org, “Zuckerberg-Backed Group Spins Immigration,” May 2013
  15. 2013Talking Points Memo on The New Yorker’s report, June 17, 2013
  16. 2004The Daily Beast, “Marco Rubio in 2004: Cheap College for Undocumented Immigrants,” Jan. 6, 2016
  17. 2004The Blaze, “Rubio Defends Past Support of Bill That Gave Undocumented Immigrants In-State Tuition,” Jan. 10, 2016
  18. 2013AILA summary of section 2103, “The DREAM Act,” in S. 744
  19. 2013Colorlines, “DREAM Act in Senate Bill Includes No Age Cap and Faster Path to Citizenship,” April 2013
  20. 2015PolitiFact on Rubio’s Univision interview and DACA, Feb. 17, 2016
  21. 2015NPR, “For Immigrants In U.S. Illegally, Rubio Favors ‘Very Long Path’ To Citizenship,” Nov. 11, 2015
  22. 2016BuzzFeed News, “Rubio: Gang Of Eight Immigration Bill Needed House To Make It A Good Bill,” Dec. 2015
  23. 2016NBC News, “Rubio: Gang of 8 Bill Never Intended to Become Law,” Feb. 15, 2016
  24. 2016Breitbart, “Jeff Sessions: Rubio Rewriting History,” Feb. 16, 2016
  25. 2015The Washington Times, “Donald Trump dubs Marco Rubio ‘king of amnesty,’” Nov. 20, 2015
  26. 2015Washington Examiner, “Trump: Rubio’s ‘pathetically weak’ immigration stance ‘ends his shot,’” Dec. 2015